This was our second time working with Colleen, she is the best! Excellent communicator and is always on point at every stage of the process. Could not recommend her more!
We had heard amazing things about Colleen McMahon's knowledge and reputation in the Pompton Plains and surrounding area. She explained every step of the process to us as we were first time home buyers. Colleen made our buying experience easy. We love our new home in Pompton Plains!
Colleen McMahon was our trusted partner in the home sale process. Her knowledge of the market, years of experience, familiarity with local laws and contractors, and assessment of competing home sales has been instrumental in the fairly quick sale of our home. She is very down to earth and we appreciated her frank and straightforward guidance in the selling process. Thank you!
Highly recommend Colleen McMahon. She is extremely knowledgeable and helped guide us through the purchase of our first home!
There was no other choice. Had dealt with her previously she's the best.
Colleen was excellent!. As a first time homebuyer, I came in with little to no knowledge on the homebuying process, but Colleen was there every step of the way to help! Colleen was extremely responsive and knowledgeable , and was able to provide excellent advice and recommendations based on my needs. I cannot reccomend Colleen enough!
Colleen was very empathetic and cared greatly about helping me sell this property under the circumstances that my family was experiencing at the time. It was much appreciated that she was kind and eager to help us out with this sale.
We honestly went into into our house sale lacking a full understanding of the value of a good real estate agent, but quickly learned how important that is. Colleen's breadth of knowledge, skill, experience, and general wisdom was extremely impressive to say the least and made our house sale a much simpler and seamless experience.
Colleen was fantastic to work with. She met us at open houses and would point out things we didn't even notice during tours. She worked with our schedule and was super flexible when we had to go back to the house to let companies in for quotes, etc. It was our first time buying a house and she made the process very easy. She answered all of our questions (there were a lot) and helped us find the perfect house!
Colleen McMahon came highly recommended and she did not disappoint. Very knowledgeable, responded quickly and made the whole process a smooth one. It is/was a pleasure to work with her.
Due to previous real-estate transactions with Colleen, I would use her and recommend her every time. Her knowledge and professional ethics are just the beginning of the wonderful things she brings to the table.
Her ability to de-stress you at a most stressful time is amazing. Colleen talked me down from the edge through the many twists and turns and spoke clearly, kindly and with the knowledge to reassure.
Colleen helped us in understanding everything with the sale of our house.
Theresa Hanrahan, DingmaThank you for all your help throughout our first home buying process. You have been so great and I appreciate all of your guidance over these past few weeks. Wishing you all the best and looking forward to running into you around town
Tim, Pompton PlainsColleen was excellent to work with. She learned our needs and suggested only possible properties that would meet our criteria. Colleen never pressured us to make any decisions and was extremely patient. She made the process easy and stress free. 100% would recommend Colleen to anyone.
Rick R. - Morris CountyMy overall experience with Century 21 Crest Real Estate and specifically Colleen A. McMahon was excellent and extremely positive. Colleen was the epitome of customer service throughout the home sale process. Throughout the sale, she responded quickly and thoroughly to all texts, calls, and emails. Colleen was patient, kind, knowledgeable, understanding, flexible, and reassuring with me, particularly as I was managing the estate sale from South Carolina and I was eager to sell the home quickly. She understood the urgency to sell the home and worked proactively to ensure the home was on the market in a timely manner and that the best sales price was obtained. Colleen held multiple open houses and provided regular updates about any prospective buyers. Colleen went "above and beyond" by bringing the last boxes of my late sister's possessions to my mother's home, which was so appreciated. Lastly, Colleen provided excellent coordination with the law firm, the buyer's realtor, and the buyer's lawyer to facilitate a smooth closing. Her communication with all parties was amazing. In closing, Colleen A. McMahon transformed a challenging situation into one that was manageable and seamless through her expertise, customer service, and communication. It is without reservation that I highly recommend Colleen A. McMahon and the team of Century 21 Crest Real Estate for your real estate needs.
Deann Borkowski, South CColleen's depth of experience in the Pequannock real estate market combined with her reputation for professionalism and speaking honestly/plainly with her clients were very important to us. We were also impressed by her responsiveness and market knowledge. She facilitated the process at every step and communicated clearly to us in terms of any expectations or timelines. Colleen was invaluable at every stage of the sale - from the pre-listing consult, to the market research to set the listing price, to the open house, the follow-up showings, the contract negotiations, and the closing. She was accessible and available to us from start to finish with knowledge and professionalism that were absolutely critical to the smoothness of our home sale.
Colleen McMahon worked hard on selling our property. Her knowledge of the town and paitence prevailed. Today's Market isn't alway easy without some bumps and Colleen helped to get us thru.
I would recommend Colleen A. McMahon to anyone who needs to sell their home.
I think they will be quite satisfied. Colleen was very professional and always available to answer our questions. She priced our house fairly and gave us advice on how to make things work for the sale.
Colleen was very profession in her presentation. I knew immediately that she had the experience and expertise to make the right decision about our home. She had researched the comps in my area and presented me with all the information along with her recommendations.
She was ahead of all issues that arose with the sale and was ready with how best to respond to them. She worked hand in had with all people we hired during the process of selling, keeping everyone informed, answering questions and moving things along when ever, and however, she could. I could not recommend her more highly.
Dec 2023Colleen's depth of experience in the Pequannock real estate market combined with her reputation for professionalism and speaking honestly/plainly with her clients were very important to us.
We were also impressed by her responsiveness and market knowledge. She facilitated the process at every step and communicated clearly to us in terms of any expectations or timelines. Colleen was invaluable at every stage of the sale - from the pre-listing consult, to the market research to set the listing price, to the open house, the follow-up showings, the contract negotiations, and the closing. She was accessible and available to us from start to finish with knowledge and professionalism that were absolutely critical to the smoothness of our home sale.
My overall experience with Century 21 Crest Real Estate and specifically Colleen A. McMahon was excellent and extremely positive. Colleen was the epitome of customer service throughout the home sale process.
Throughout the sale, she responded quickly and thoroughly to all texts, calls, and emails. Colleen was patient, kind, knowledgeable, understanding, flexible, and reassuring with me, particularly as I was managing the estate sale from South Carolina and I was eager to sell the home quickly. She understood the urgency to sell the home and worked proactively to ensure the home was on the market in a timely manner and that the best sales price was obtained. Colleen held multiple open houses and provided regular updates about any prospective buyers. Colleen went "above and beyond" by bringing the last boxes of my late sister's possessions to my mother's home, which was so appreciated. Lastly, Colleen provided excellent coordination with the law firm, the buyer's realtor, and the buyer's lawyer to facilitate a smooth closing. Her communication with all parties was amazing. In closing, Colleen A. McMahon transformed a challenging situation into one that was manageable and seamless through her expertise, customer service, and communication. It is without reservation that I highly recommend Colleen A. McMahon and the team of Century 21 Crest Real Estate for your real estate needs.
Jan 2023
Colleen was excellent to work with. She learned our needs and suggested only possible properties that would meet our criteria. Colleen never pressured us to make any decisions and was extremely patient. She made the process easy and stress free. 100% would recommend Colleen to anyone. Dec 2022
Thank you for all your help throughout our first home buying process. You have been so great and I appreciate all of your guidance over these past few weeks. Wishing you all the best and looking forward to running into you around town
Colleen helped us in understanding everything with the sale of our house.
Colleen was very knowledgeable of the market and was very patient in answering all our questions.
Chris Mulligan Hamburg NJ
August 2022Colleen helped us navigate this tough market. She understood what we were looking for and was patient and persistent until we found our dream home.
Her local knowledge is invaluable. It was a pleasure to work with her through every step of this process!
Denise Taylor, Pompton Plains
August 2022I felt Colleen went above and beyond. She was on top of everything and helped us first time home buyers every step of the way! She is kind, trustworthy, and answered every question we had - and we had a lot! I would recommend her to anyone and everyone, hands down.
Valerie Long, Pompton Pl
July 2022Colleen McMahon was extremely helpful and patient. This was my first time selling a house, so I had many questions. She answered them all professionally and completely. She made the whole process easy. I would recommend Colleen to all my friends and family.
Janet Ryan Pompton Plain
June 2022Thank you for hanging in there and dealing with all the issues!!
Sandy leo
April, 2022Thank you for making it easy :)
Philip Arena
March 2022Colleen was incredible to have as first time home buyers, she was very patient and helpful throughout the process since this was all new for us. March 2022
Colleen came to the house and sat with my mother for a long time to insure she was comfortable and ready to move ahead. She allowed my mom to talk about her memories of living in town which also made my mother feel at ease. She provided good info on the sale tactic and expectations along with input on how to prep the house for showing. Sold it over-asking in no time. All around good job from start to finish.
Colleen's strong attention to detail and knowledge about real estate was very impressive. I knew I was in good hands and that she would help find the perfect first home for me and my fiancé! I would strongly recommend Colleen to my family and friends.
Because of a previous selling experience, I knew Colleen was the best possible choice to market my home. She is the ultimate professional. She is also the Energizer bunny!
Colleen took care of everything. I had very little to do except prepare for my move and she even helped with that. I have used Colleen before and have recommended to my friends and colleagues. They have also used her. I couldn't be happier with the performance of Colleen A, McMahon.
Colleen was incredible to have as first time home buyers, she was very patient and helpful throughout the process since this was all new for us.
Colleen,
Thank you for making it easy :)
Colleen was super helpful and responsive! We couldn't be more thankful for her advice and direction! Colleen gets an A+++ in my book!! D Kelly Pompton Plains, NJ
Tom and Deb K, Home Seller in Pompton Plains, NJ , Agent: Colleen McMahon
Colleen is so knowledgeable in every aspect of real estate and was there every step of the way for me.
October 2021
I always knew that when it was time for me to start the process of buying a house, I would go with Colleen! Having known her for most of my life, I knew that she was someone I could trust with such an important process.
Beyond my personal experience with her, her reputation is unmatched. I knew that she would be incredibly knowledgeable about any of the towns we looked in, in addition to the ins and outs of the houses we saw. Working with someone I could trust and whose input I value was of the utmost importance to me.
Colleen was amazing in all of the above aspects. She is SO knowledgeable about everything - the houses themselves and the communities they're in. She was able to find us the perfect neighborhood that I had no idea existed! She made the whole overwhelming process incredibly smooth and easy.
Colleen went above and beyond all of my expectations of an agent. She was constantly available for questions and concerns. She was patient with us and extremely informative throughout the whole process. She made us feel comfortable each step of the way.
Casey McMahon/Podence was also INCREDIBLY helpful and fantastic throughout our search. She worked so hard alongside Colleen to help find us properties that fit our wants and needs. Casey was also incredibly knowledgeable about the properties we saw and the communities we visited. She also made us feel comfortable throughout our search.
Colleen and Casey helped to make our experience as easy and smooth as possible. I'd recommend them to anyone (but especially other first time home buyers!) in a heartbeat. Truly a dynamic duo
October 2021
The patience Colleen showed my daughter & son in law when they were shopping for a house. I knew that she would not let us down in the selling our home with moral integrity. I met her through my daughter & quickly realized how professional, knowledgeable, personable, understanding, & comical Colleen really is. She is more than just a realtor to us, she has become a friend!
Excellent service! Excellent knowledge of where our home was, even though 40 minutes away from C21 office. Excellent job overall! But most importantly: EXCELLENT SALES REP COLLEEN!!! Love her!!
Will always recommend Colleen & C21 to our family & friends. Thank you!!
October 2021
Colleen was super helpful and responsive! We couldn't be more thankful for her advice and direction! Colleen gets an A+++ in my book!! D Kelly Pompton Plains, NJ
The selling of a home could be a daunting ordeal and a very stressful time but Colleen made it seamless from contract to closing.
Every question we had Colleen was able to answer or provide a reasonable solution. I am positive that we sold because of her effort and attention to details which was crucial to the sale of my home. I will definitely recommend her to all my friends and family. Joseph P. Pompton Lakes, NJ
Colleen always had patience with us after 6 months of searching and losing bids. Her energy is always the same. She had time to explain all we needed to know about homes since it was our first time. Demanya Hamburg NJ
Colleen was very professional and provided timely insights in the search for my new home. Her knowledge of the surrounding area was helpful. I would recommend Colleen to anyone looking in the area to sell or buy a home. Karin P Bloomingdale, NJ
Thank you for everything you did to help me with this. It can be stressful and difficult at times going through the home buying process, but you made it easy. Thank you again. P Dillon Hewitt, NJ
We were looking for a house for almost 5 years . As a first time buyer nobody was able to convince us to buy a house. But Colleen really helped us each and every step to understand the situation and make a deal. To buy a house is a long time investment from our savings so Colleen helped us to build this trust and move ahead with the deal. P S, Lincoln Park, NJ
It took us awhile to find the right condo, but Colleen A. McMahon never pressured us into settling for something that wasn't right for us. She patiently kept taking us to see many different locations, until we found the right one. SM Hamburg, NJ
I would highly recommend Colleen to friends and family! Extremely trustworthy and has your best interest at all times. It was a very smooth transaction from beginning to end!All positive! If you want an excellent realtor, you need to contact Colleen! VR Butler, NJ
"The selling of a home could be a daunting ordeal and a very stressful time but Colleen made it seamless from contract to closing. Every question we had Colleen was able to answer or provide a reasonable solution.
I am positive that our sold because of her effort and attention to details which was crucial to the sale of my home. I will definitely recommend her to all my friends and family."
Joseph Puzzo (Seller)
"Colleen was very professional and provided timely insights in the search for my new home. Her knowledge of the surrounding area was helpful. I would recommend Colleen to anyone looking in the area to sell or buy a home."
Karin Pilaar (Buyer)
"Colleen is the best real estate agent there is. I've used her in the past and was always very happy and satisfied with the experience. I recommend her all the time when people are thinking about buying or selling a home."
"We are looking for house almost 5 years . As a first time buyer nobody able to convince us to buy a house. But Colleen really help us each and every steps to understand the situation and make a deal done. To buy a house is a long time investment from our saving so Colleen help us to build this trust and move ahead with the deal."
Colleen's record is proven and she knows what she is doing. She kept us on track and up to date on what was happening from the time we initially discussed putting mom's house on the market, until the day it officially closed. Colleen listened to us and acted on any marketing changes we requested. She communicated very well in person, as well as via text and email. Her networking skills are remarkable she knows who to have you contact to get things done. Colleen is very personable, yet maintains a professional manner. It was a pleasure working with her for the last 10 weeks
Colleen was fabulous from the start of searching homes up until closing. She was always punctual and met the needs of our requirements when looking for a home. She also was very knowledgeable in the area we found a home in and guided us in the right direction. I would definitely use Colleen for future home purchasesColleen is an absolutely outstanding realtor in every way. She's very intelligent, considerate, skillful, and hard-working. We really enjoyed getting to know her while our house was on the market.
She instructed us in making our house look its best, she knew just how to attract the right buyer, and she navigated us smoothly through the sale process. We had to be out of the country during part of the process but had no worries leaving everything in Colleen's hands. We LOVE her!
I want to thank Colleen for being so great during the whole process of selling my house. She was kind and courteous and answered all my questions and always kept in contact with me. It was a pleasure having her as my realtor. I will be referring my friends to her.
CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate
Northern New Jersey Full-Service Real Estate — Residential, New Construction, Commercial, Investment, Rentals
